Drinks & Dining Guide to Carlisle, PA
Carlisle, Pennsylvania is such a relaxed place with a multitude of sights to see and historic places to visit. Because of its location in Pennsylvania, Carlisle is easy to get to for a weekend getaway or just a stop for lunch on your way through. Speaking of stopping for lunch, Carlisle has some amazing restaurants for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, as well as some sweet locations for dessert. In this companion drinks & dining guide to Carlisle, PA we will whet your appetite and let you in on some hidden gems in the heart of city.
The culinary scene in Carlisle is incredibly lively and diverse with something for every pallet. If you are hankering for gourmet chocolate, a steaming bowl of Pho, or a delicious breakfast Crêpe, Carlisle’s array of restaurants will deliver. Read on for some great ideas to wet your whistle and satisfy your appetite.
Breakfast & Brunch Bites
Why not start your day off right with a hearty and filling breakfast before your day’s adventure? With breakfast in mind, Carlisle has so many places to choose from so here are just a few to get you going.
Denim Coffee
Denim Coffee on S Hanover St and has everything you could want in a coffee shop. Picture a few locals sipping their espresso, enjoying the free wifi while watching the world go by through the floor-to-ceiling glass windows. The aroma of freshly brewed coffee envelops you as you walk in. Grab your morning coffee along an amazing breakfast sandwich. Their breakfast sandwich is one of the best I have had in a VERY long time! Denim Coffee makes your coffee any way you like. Choose something from their full espresso & specialty coffee menu or buy a bag of freshly roasted beans to take home.
The Sunrise Cafe Sandwich Shop
The Sunrise Cafe is a favorite in Carlisle for breakfast and lunch. The cafe is located on N Hanover St. in a beautifully remodeled Victorian home. This charming cafe and sandwich shop offers counter service only so just place your order at the counter, sit anywhere you prefer, even outdoors and someone will bring your food over when it’s ready. Enjoy a mouthwatering sticky bun or a wonderful homemade muffin while you sit on the porch and watch the world go by.
Hamilton Restaurant
As you stroll W High Street you will notice Hamilton on the intersection of N Pitt Street. The building is distinctive because of its brick exterior and huge white lettering. Hamiltons has been a staple in Carlisle since 1939. They are famous for their Hot Chee-Dog, a hot dog topped with cheese, chili & mustard. This old-fashioned, large-plate diner is just what you would imagine. Hamilton offers cozy booths and long lunch counter full of locals and visitors alike. The restaurant is open all day but their large potions make a filling and hearty breakfast or brunch.
Helena's Chocolate Café and Crêperie
If you haven’t guessed already, Helena’s Chocolate Café and Crêperie has a distinctly French flair. If you are interested in an adventurous breakfast or brunch with a beautiful presentation look no further than Helena’s on W High Street. The Bacon, Egg, and Gruyere Crêpe is highly recommended, or choose something from their espresso bar for your morning boost.
Loveable Lunch Options
After antiquing all morning or shopping along High and Hanover Streets you will be hungry for an afternoon bite. With lunch on the brain, open your Drinks & Dining Guide to Carlisle and enjoy one of these mouth-watering lunch options.
Grazery
Located on High St, the Grazery has perfected a healthy, but not boring lunch or brunch! Healthy and creative, meets small batch from scratch cooking. They have a small menu but everything is seasonal and delicious. The Grazery specializes in soups, salads & sandwiches with gluten-free & vegan options so stop in for lunch when you visit Carlisle.
B&L Caribbean Restaurant
Enjoy a stroll along the pastel-colored buildings on W Pomfret Street. You will come across a cheerful building with the Saint Lucian flag fluttering in the light breeze. Growing up in the Caribbean, I was very familiar with the delicious aromas wafting out of this adorable restaurant. Some of you may be familiar with jerk chicken and sweet plantains but there is much much more to Caribbean cuisine.
B&L’s chef and owner is from Saint Lucia and he stays true to his homeland as well as its surrounding islands. Walking into B&L Caribbean Restaurant you are greeted with a smile and the distant sound of reggae or steel drums. B&L Caribbean Restaurant offers diners a simple indoor dining space, or in the warmer months a nice back patio. The food is so delicious but beware, some dishes have some heat! They have a rotating variety of Caribbean favorites available to dine in or takeout. Jerk chicken, curried goat, or stewed oxtail are served with a traditional side dish of rice & beans among others. I recommend grabbing a Jamaican beef patty, just let them know if you want it spicy or mild!
Redd's Smokehouse BBQ
Redd’s has been serving up its classic barbecue since 2010 on N Hanover St. They believe in doing things the old-fashioned way so you can follow your nose right to the front door. Redds’s smokers are always going and the results are a delicious array of smoked meats. Feast on their delicious chicken, pulled pork, and beef brisket along with homemade cornbread. Redd’s continues to serve large portions keeping customers always coming back for more. Sit down or order something to go from this modest and humble BBQ joint, including one of their four signature sauces!
North Hanover Grille
When looking for a simple and friendly bar & grill for a quick bite and a pint, the North Hanover Grille is the place for you! This bar and grille offers a standard American menu with a large list of draft beers. Take a seat at a table or cozy up to the bar to enjoy a basket of wings or a delicious burger. The N Hanover Grille is an affordable, no-frills establishment serving everything you might enjoy with a down-home atmosphere. The happy hour drink special are fantastic and the service is warm and inviting. I recommend stopping in for a hearty lunch before you hit the antique mall across the street.
Issei Noodle
Well…If you are into asian fusion you are going to LOVE Issei Noodle! Voted best in Cumberland County year after year this warm and inviting restaurant not only specializes in feng shui but wows your taste buds. Try one of their savory ramen or an amazing donburi bowl, then wash it down with a special bubble tea. Issei Noodle offers guests a window into another culture where food is its centerpiece. Everything is lovingly prepared from fresh, quality ingredients and authentic flavors. Their motto is Peace, Love & Ramen! What more could you want?
Taqueria Laurita
Some of the most flavorful and affordable Mexican street eats can be found at Taqueria Laurita. This simple, no-frills joint on N Hanover St is the perfect spot to grab lunch to-go for a days adventure. Enjoy their tacos, burritos, tostadas, and empanadas. They are only open for lunch so plan accordingly. If you are hungry and you simply want a tasty, reasonably priced lunch stop in to Taqueria Laurita. The taco of the week is always something tasty and exciting.
Winner Dinner Spots
Whether you are looking for a quiet intimate meal, an exotic and flavorful adventure, or a deliciously filling dinner you can find it all in Carlisle. Our Drinks & Dining Guide to Carlisle offers a few of our favorite dinner spots to try.
Café Bruges
If you haven’t explored Belgian food before you should make a point to have dinner at Café Bruges bistro. Belgium is famous for its comfort food like waffles, chocolate, and beer but there is so much more to enjoy. Café Bruges on N Pitt Street serves up some of the most amazing Carbonade Flamande, Stoemp Saucisse, and quiche. In addition try their crispy frites, melt-in-your-mouth steak, and a scrumptious Belgian Dark Chocolate Mousse! Café Bruges is also celebrated for serving over 100 different Belgian beers. Sample something new while you are transported to a new world of cuisine without leaving the country.
1794 The Whiskey Rebellion
The Whiskey Rebellion is a restaurant that mixes the mystery of history in a fun and lively way. Sit by the fireplace and sip one of their American or international whiskey as you take a step back in time to the late 18th century. In the year 1794 the Whiskey Rebellion set up an encampment on the premises of the Comfort Suites, adjoining this restaurant. 1794 The Whiskey Rebellion on S Hanover Street serves up a plethora of fine cuts and American bistro fare. You can enjoy your dinner indoors or they offer outdoor dining as well. You should definitely stop in for a great meal and a slice of historic Carlisle.
Mount Fuji
Located on N Hanover Street Mount Fuji specializes in Japanese cuisine. It’s a local standby for an array of entrees including sushi, bento boxes, tempura, teriyaki, and vegetarian-friendly dishes. Currently, they are doing take-out only but the presentation and flavors remain the same. For a flavorful dinner, pick up sushi from Mount Fuji and have a picnic in your hotel or at one of the many public parks throughout Carlisle.
One 13 Social
If you are looking for a globally inspired menu with an incredible wine list, look no further than One13 Social. This upscale yet casual eatery is certainly a feast for the senses. This great restaurant on W High Street is in a beautifully restored corner building. The ambiance inside is warm and intimate with an exquisitely decorated interior, some say the best in Carlisle. Their menu is detailed without being overwhelming and the cocktail menu, draft list, and selection of fine wines is well appointed. One13 Social is a wonderful gathering spot for a perfectly plated meal with friends or to impress someone special.
Yak N Yeti II
Yak N Yeti on W High Street is another international restaurant, this time serving exotic Bhutanese and Nepalese cuisines with vegan and vegetarian offerings. This family-owned restaurant is committed to serving fresh and traditional dishes from the Himalayas. The aromas and flavors of the dishes at Yak N Yeti are something unique and special, all served with your desired level of heat. As you walk in you will be greeted by the colorful art and decorations of the Himalayan region in their cozy dining room. If you have never tried food from Nepal and Bhutan and you feel adventurous, your server can certainly make wonderful meal suggestions. Yak N Yeti is BYOB so bring your favorite beverage and enjoy this incredibly unique and flavorful menu when you visit.
Seve-N-Dots Pizza
If you are keen on a simple, relaxed place for great pizza and craft beer then Seve-N-Dots has you covered. Hidden away on E Louther Street, Seve-N-Dots offers a laid-back dining experience. Dine in, take out, or sit outside with a delicious brick oven pie. Enjoy a tasty, cold craft brew from their very own onsite artisan brewery. Seve-N-Dots has been ranked 8th best pizza in Pennsylvania so taste it for yourself when you are in the area.
Lively Libation Locations
A Drinks & Dining Guide to Carlisle would not be complete without the drinks! Some of the best cocktails and brews in Carlisle are right in the heart of town. If you stay downtown you can wander to your heart’s content…and pop in somewhere for a pleasant evening.
Fun Fact: The Borough has passed an open container ordinance allowing people to take their cocktails with them throughout the downtown area! Just ask for it to-go.
Molly Pitcher Brewing Company
Molly Pitcher is Carlisle’s local heroine so it only makes sense that she is the symbol of Carlisle’s brewery. Walking into the Molly Pitcher Brewing Company on W High St. entices customers with the smell of malt, and hops and oozes brewer charm. The star of the show is the draft beer list. Their brews have fun, quirky names that fit perfectly with the Revolutionary-era decor. Their menu is a great mix of flavors with the addition of a fantastic array of bar snacks. Drop in for a pint with a snack and stay for their bar trivia or live music.
Grand Illusion Hard Cider
Grand Illusion is a distinctive watering hole located on W High St. They offer the world’s largest selection of Pennsylvania cider on draft, as well as eight Pennsylvania wines. Pop in and try a fight of cider, then challenge your friends to an onsite escape room. Grand Illusion Hard Cider has such a wide selection of cider, one for every pallet, you won’t be disappointed. The atmosphere is relaxed with indoor and outdoor seating and a very well-rounded food menu. Grand Illusion makes a wonderful destination, or one-stop on your pub crawl.
Hook & Flask Still Works
The Hook & Flask Still Works located on N Hanover St. has a strong lineup of beer and wine but the specialties are their craft cocktails! The Hook & Flask pays tribute to firefighters and all emergency services personnel with every pour. Housemade spirits transformed into tasty and bold libations with names that reflect the owner’s firefighting heritage. Stop in for a Redheaded Firefighter, Campfire Whisky, or the Spice of Life…you won’t be disappointed.
The Gingerbread Man
If you’re looking for a neighborhood pub vibe with an Irish twist and something cold on a hot day, you should stop into the Gingerbread Man. Tucked away on S Courthouse Ave along a narrow one-way street sits this homey bar and restaurant that has been in business for over 50 years. Step inside and marvel at the huge handcrafted bar with gingerbread details all the way up to the ceiling! The Gingerbread Man is known for their affordable wing special on Monday nights in addition to excellent happy hour specials everyday! Grab a table, cozy up to the bar, or choose our personal favorite, a bar snug. Sláinte.
Market Cross Pub & Brewery
The Market Cross Pub and Brewery is very much your traditional British pub nestled into the heart of Carlisle on N Hanover St. The lively atmosphere is warm and welcoming giving patrons a glimpse into what cozy English pub life is all about. Good food and tasty beer! Try their fantastic fish and chips for lunch or dinner and wash it down with an English Red Ale, among others. The Brewery at Market Cross Pub boasts roughly 15 styles of English ales and lagers rotating throughout the year. There is always something new on tap.
1794 The Whiskey Rebellion…again
If you enjoy Whiskey, Scotch, or Bourbon in any form, 1794 The Whiskey Rebellion is the place for you. From barrel to glass you won’t find more whisky options anywhere in the area. Taste one of their 50 international whiskeys or order one of their classic cocktails. You will be sure to enjoy the elixir of your choice.
Delicious Dessert Destinations
Craving a sweet treat after dinner or a decadent and refreshing ice cream cone on a hot day is even more enjoyable on vacation. Carlisle has quite a few options for any sweet tooth but here are just a few to sample while you’re in town.
Mummert Chocolates
Handmade Swiss chocolates…who could want more? At Mummert Chocolates on W Pomfret St, they specialize in an array of carefully crafted chocolates along with other sweet confections. This family-owned gourmet chocolate shop offers gift baskets and boxes for all occasions. If you prefer milk or dark, salty or sweet, soft or chewy, stop in and enjoy one, two, or a whole box.
Dough & Arrows Carlisle Edible Cookie Dough & Ice Cream
This place takes your taste buds on a delectable journey through their variety of sweet treats. Dough & Arrows Carlisle is famous for their edible cookie dough so if you loved licking the spoon as a kid, Dough & Arrows is a stop that will bring you back to your childhood. With a fun and friendly atmosphere, quirky table games and even vegan options Dough & Arrows is a must-taste spot.
Leo's Homemade Ice Cream
If you are walking around Carlisle on a hot day you may find yourself in the market for an affordable and tasty cone filled with delicious handmade ice cream. Leo’s has been scooping up their delicious ice cream since 2003. The owner is an ice cream flavor genius and he comes up with some unique flavors as well as the classics. Check out this great cash-only establishment on W High St. next time you visit Carlisle.
Helena's Chocolate Café and Crêperie…again
Helena’s Chocolate Café and Crêperie on W High St offer unique twists on traditional French crêpes but there is so much more available for dessert. Sample a delectable macaron or buy a box to take home. Indulge in a sweet crêpe with traditional or unique toppings. Try one of their fantastic éclairs, cookies, scones, or the plethora of assorted cakes they offer. Stop in and let your taste buds run wild!
Exquisite Chocolates of Carlisle
Heralded as the taste of Belgium, Exquisite Chocolates of Carlisle is just that, no passport required! If you LOVE chocolate this is the place for you! The shop displays its immense collection of confections in such a beautiful way, it draws you in immediately. The staff is incredibly knowledgeable so they can recommend chocolates and confections that everyone will enjoy. Follow your sweet tooth to their location on S Hanover St. for a tasty treat you won’t easily forget.
Beeman's Baked Goods
If you have a hankering for a scratch-made Pennsylvania Dutch treat please follow your nose to Beeman’s Baked Goods on S Orange St. This family-owned and operated establishment makes delicious pies, cakes, pastries, cookies, and bread, just to name a few. Beeman’s is known for its friendly service and their Pennsylvania Dutch fastnachts. Fastnachts are traditional potato donuts and should definitely be sampled during your visit to Pennsylvania!
Well, here ends our delicious journey through the incredible array of Carlisle’s culinary delights. There is something for everyone in Carlisle so please put this great town on your list to visit any time of year! During the spring, summer, and fall plan on sampling dishes and confections featuring all the locally sourced fresh fruits and vegetables, or visit during the winter for hot cocoa, hearty comforting meals, and warming libations. You won’t be disappointed! Enjoy.
If you enjoyed this companion Drinks & Dining Guide to Carlisle, PA. If you did, make sure to check out these other posts you might like.
